By the time you're choosing between two or three agencies the pitches start to sound alike, and very little of what's said in a meeting can be checked there and then.
Figures can at least be pinned down, so ask for them. Then ask what sits behind each one. The second answer is the useful one when you're comparing agencies for sales recruitment.
These are ours, across our business, and you're welcome to question any of them.
- 79% of the roles we take on, we fill
- 95% of the people we place are still there 18 months later
- 92% of our clients come back to us for their next hire
- 881 client companies
None of them proves much on its own, since anyone can put a number on a website. What they give you is something specific to push on, and the way an agency answers when you push is worth listening to.
What's inside each one
What the fill rate counts. It includes everything we said yes to, so if we took a role on and couldn't fill it, it's in there and counts against us. So is a role a client paused halfway through and never restarted. Someone quoting close to 100% may be counting a different set of roles, and it's fair to ask how they count.
Why retention matters to us. By month four the fee has long since been paid and the guarantee has ended, so if a placement walked out, what we'd lose is the next role, because few clients go back to an agency whose last hire disappeared within the year.
What repeat business shows. We collect testimonials and we're glad to have them. They tell you how someone felt. The 92% tells you that most clients came back with their next role when they could have gone anywhere, which is a harder thing to arrange.
Whether it's luck. The client count answers that. A good fill rate over a dozen clients could be one good year, while over 881 companies it says more about how the business runs month to month.
Checking any figure you're given
Ask what the number is out of. A fill rate is a share of something, and the something matters. Ask over what period, too, and whether it covers the whole business or one team in a good year.
Then ask for an example of a role that didn't work and what happened next, because every agency has them, and listen carefully to how they talk about it.
Three questions where answers really differ
Ask what happens if the hire doesn't work out, and get the answer in writing. Guarantees vary a lot in how long they last and what they cover, and ours is a three-month replacement and rebate guarantee.
Ask whether the fee moves when the salary does. Percentage fees are common, which means stretching an offer for your first choice costs you more. With fixed fees agreed upfront, the fee stays the same whatever the final salary turns out to be.
Ask who'll actually be doing the searching, and whether you can speak to them before you sign anything, since the answer says a lot about how much attention your role will get once the contract's in place.
Clients don't come back when the answers fall apart once the contract's signed, and across our business 92% of our clients come back for their next hire.
Book a short call and put the same three questions to us on a real vacancy. Or use the green Tell Us About Your Role button to send us the role in about a minute, and we'll come back to you within 20 minutes during UK office hours.















