They'd Been Looking for Four Months. We Shortlisted One Person.

A four-month engineering vacancy, filled in about four weeks off a shortlist of one. Here's why one was the right number.

By
Mark Wilkinson
,
Managing Director
of Coburg Banks
LinkedIn Profile
November 5, 2026

This one had been open for four months before it reached us, and the client had tried just about everything in that time.

The business supplies and services commercial equipment across hospitality and care. An engineer had left, and they'd been trying to replace him ever since, first on their own and then through other agencies. Nothing they tried had stuck. Meanwhile the engineers they still had were covering on overtime, which is manageable for a couple of weeks and a real problem over four months.

That gets expensive quickly, and some of the service contracts weren't being looked after the way the client wanted.

Not a bobby basic engineer

The job title said field service engineer. Take that at face value and you'll find plenty of them.

What they actually needed was someone strong on the electrical side, who could pick up a schematic or a wiring diagram, read it properly and work out the fault from it (as opposed to swapping parts until the problem goes away, which is how a fair few call-outs get "fixed"). That's a much smaller group of people. And it's the part the earlier searches seem to have missed.

Our guess is they shortlisted on job title, which you can't really blame anyone for, and every engineer on those lists would have looked right on paper while none of them could do what this client needed.

Asking for evidence

We advertised, then screened every application for that one skill. Every job history looked fine, so we needed something else to go on, and the obvious thing was to ask them to show us.

Instead of taking "electrical experience" on trust, we asked every candidate to walk us through the last fault they'd found from a drawing. What was on it, and where did they start? People who've really done it answer straight away, usually with more detail than you asked for. Anyone who hasn't tends to go vague.

A good number went vague, so we turned them down, some of them perfectly decent engineers who just weren't right for this, which is never a nice call to make. Which left a shortlist of one name, and a decision about whether to send it.

Sending one name

A shortlist of one isn't something we enjoy sending. Clients want a choice, and a single name can look like we didn't try very hard. But the brief was tight, and padding it out would only have handed the rejecting back to the client, along with a fortnight of interviews.

So we sent him with a short note explaining why he was the only one.

The client tested him in detail as part of their own process, and he passed with flying colours and got the job. Start to finish it took us about four weeks, against the four months they'd spent before.

If you're hiring one yourself

Put a real drawing in front of them. A schematic from your own kit is ideal, with a fault you already know the answer to. If you haven't got one to hand, a manufacturer's drawing for a common piece of kit works almost as well. Ask how they'd go about finding it, then just listen, and you'll learn more in ten minutes than from the whole CV.

Pay attention to the order they'd do things in, because somebody who's diagnosed from drawings for years has a routine that comes out without them thinking about it. The ones who haven't will usually reach for the parts list.

And be ready to turn down good engineers. That's the hard bit, because they're often pleasant, experienced people who'd be fine in a different job. It's also the part clients rarely see, and on this role it made the difference.

Four months of looking ended about four weeks after the brief reached us, against an average time to hire across our business of 29 days.

If your field service role keeps attracting people who are nearly right, book a call and bring a drawing with you. Or use the green Tell Us About Your Role button to send us the role in about a minute, and we'll come back to you within 20 minutes during UK office hours.

Coburg Banks Engineering & Operations Recruitment
We help great engineering professionals get brilliant jobs in top companies.

Continue reading

Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

A 25-Person Site Became 950. Who Hired the Managers?

Renishaw has built a hall it hasn't filled yet, and the hardest thing to source for it isn't the machinery or the floor space.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

7 Reasons Why Skilled Engineers Are Vital to Your Business

Skilled engineers drive innovation, efficiency, and growth in your business. Discover how they solve complex problems and ensure top-quality products.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

The Deficit Numbers Nobody in Engineering Is Reading Yet

Government borrowing just missed forecasts again. Here's what that tends to do to the time it takes to fill a senior engineering role.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

The £50,271 Line Every Sponsoring Manufacturer Should Know

The Home Office's settlement overhaul turns one salary figure into a hiring decision for manufacturers that sponsor engineering managers.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

Budget Incentives Need an Owner. Who Runs the Project?

Higher allowances and defence money create projects, and projects need senior managers that manufacturers are finding dearer to employ.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

One Carmaker Is Hiring. The Other Just Cut 4,000 Jobs

Two carmakers, two completely opposite weeks, and what the contrast means if you are hiring engineering leadership right now.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

Upgrading a Live Plant? Hire the Maintenance Manager First

A £161m upgrade at Mars's Melton Mowbray plant shows why the riskiest part of modernising a working factory is the manager, not the machinery.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

A £350m Cable Factory Just Opened. Who Will Run It?

A £350m subsea cable plant has opened in the Highlands. Its operators are training in Japan, but its managers must come from closer to home.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

Manufacturers Are Hiring Less. The Senior Hire Can't Wait

Manufacturer hiring has nearly stalled, but the senior engineering hire is the one gap that costs more the longer it stays open.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

The Pool Leaned Electrical. They Needed a Mechanical Engineer.

A restructure left a maintenance team short. Most engineers lean electrical, and we found the mechanical specialist in under four weeks.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

We Got It Wrong First Time. Then We Ran It Again.

An engineer walked out with no notice. Our first candidate wasn't right, so we started over and still filled it in about four weeks.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

How Our Tools Help You Justify Engineering Hiring Decisions

Struggling to justify your next engineering hire? Discover how data-driven hiring can reduce risks, secure stakeholder approval, and ensure the perfect fit.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

Why a Manufacturer Came Back to Us for Its Second Engineer

A manufacturer came back to us for the second engineer in its rebuilt maintenance team. How that search went, and how we work.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

Someone Resigned This Morning. Here's What the Next Four Weeks Look Like.

A week-by-week view of what happens when you need an engineer replaced quickly and can't afford to get it wrong twice.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

Four Steps, and the One Everybody Rushes

What actually happens when you hand us an engineering role, and which step decides whether it works.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

Why a Manufacturer Came Back to Us for Its Second Engineer

A manufacturer came back to us for the second engineer in its rebuilt maintenance team. How that search went, and how we work.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

Someone Resigned This Morning. Here's What the Next Four Weeks Look Like.

A week-by-week view of what happens when you need an engineer replaced quickly and can't afford to get it wrong twice.
Coburg Banks Engineering Recruitment Agency

Four Steps, and the One Everybody Rushes

What actually happens when you hand us an engineering role, and which step decides whether it works.